User vote - should the forums be upgraded, or kept?

  • Topic Is Sticky
  • Poll
  • 3.3K Views
  • Last Post 09 January 2017
Keep the existing forums and fix. (0 Votes)
0 vote
Wipe the forums and upgrade. (30 Votes)
30 vote
Total Votes: 30
Mike posted this 05 January 2017 - Last edited 05 January 2017

So these forums are based on a many-year-old version of MVCForum. And while it mostly works pretty well there are some annoying bugs in it and things that don't work as well as they should.

Unfortunately I can't perform a straight upgrade of the forums, the databases are too different for a migration to work. So it'd be an all-or-nothing approach.

This would sadly mean that everyone would have to re-register. The plan would be to keep the old forums around on a different subdomain so users could continue to access them for a while until everything was sorted.

However it would mean a slightly better design, better spam filtering and better search.

So what do you guys think?

2 Comments
Order By: Standard | Newest | Votes
kirashi posted this 09 January 2017

So these forums are based on a many-year-old version of MVCForum. And while it mostly works pretty well there are some annoying bugs in it and things that don't work as well as they should.

So what do you guys think?

I think it'd be great, since MVCForum is... well, getting old. But what would you consider switching over to? I'm a big fan of IP.Board products, however, I'm aware they aren't free so they're definitely not the be-all end-all forum software of choice.

My second choices would be bbPress, which runs off a WordPress-based site installation, or Discourse, which is free to host on your own server. Last resort options would be phpBB, and then vBulletin, but I'm not too fond of these two since they seem to get exploited more often than others...

So which forum software were you thinking of upgrading to?

Mike posted this 09 January 2017

A newer version of the same board. Not switching platform, but because of the modifications ive made I can't upgrade to a newer version of MVCForum